Tax Fairness by Convention

Released on by Ira Lindsay
preview-18

  • Tax Fairness by Convention Book Detail

  • Author : Ira Lindsay
  • Release Date : 2016
  • Publisher :
  • Genre :
  • Pages : 41
  • ISBN 13 :
  • File Size : 82,82 MB
DOWNLOAD BOOK

Tax Fairness by Convention by Ira Lindsay PDF Summary

Book Description: Horizontal equity is the principle that people who earn equal income should owe equal tax. It has gotten a bad name. Although horizontal equity remains a textbook criterion of tax fairness, scholarly literature is largely hostile. Scholars ranging from the legal theorist Louis Kaplow to philosophers Thomas Nagel and Liam Murphy question its conceptual coherence and normative significance. The crux of the case against horizontal equity is that it seems irrational to worry about the relationship between pre-tax income and tax obligations rather than determining tax policy in light of what our best theory of distributive justice tells us is the best post-tax outcome. I argue that horizontal equity is best understood as a compromise principle for people who disagree about deeper principles of distributive justice. The debate over horizontal equity reflects two distinct ways of thinking about fairness. One approach starts with principles that specify a just distribution of income, resources or utility and uses these principles to derive appropriate tax laws. A second approach analyzes fairness norms as stable and mutually advantageous compromises between people who have conflicting interests and differing moral commitments. Proponents and opponents of redistributive taxation can agree that at any given level of redistribution they will each be better off if taxes are horizontally equitable. Horizontally equitable taxation can thus prevent rent-seeking and ideological conflict over tax policy from generating a wasteful patchwork of narrow taxes and tax subsidies. Observing horizontal equity may be unimportant when people agree on ideal principles of justice and the relevant empirical facts. But under more usual conditions of deep moral and empirical disagreement over tax policy, treating pre-tax income as a normative baseline can prevent conflict over distributive questions from leading to wasteful and inequitable tax policy.

Disclaimer: www.yourbookbest.com does not own Tax Fairness by Convention books pdf, neither created or scanned. We just provide the link that is already available on the internet, public domain and in Google Drive. If any way it violates the law or has any issues, then kindly mail us via contact us page to request the removal of the link.

Tax Fairness by Convention

Tax Fairness by Convention

File Size : 12,12 MB
Total View : 2340 Views
DOWNLOAD

Horizontal equity is the principle that people who earn equal income should owe equal tax. It has gotten a bad name. Although horizontal equity remains a textbo

Global Tax Fairness

Global Tax Fairness

File Size : 29,29 MB
Total View : 1827 Views
DOWNLOAD

This book addresses sixteen different reform proposals that are urgently needed to correct the fault lines in the international tax system as it exists today, a

Tax Fairness and Folk Justice

Tax Fairness and Folk Justice

File Size : 29,29 MB
Total View : 6068 Views
DOWNLOAD

Much of the discussion of tax fairness today focuses on distribution - who gets what. But this is too limited a focus. To the average person, tax fairness means